×

or

The Protection & Indemnity (P&I) Club of the Shipping World

The Protection & Indemnity (P&I) Club of the Shipping World

P&I Insurance is third party liability insurance for the ship owners, operators or charterers. The carriage of cargos from load port to the destined port involves a high risk to the ship owner, charterer and the cargo owner in the form of cargo damages due to the carriage, war risks, and risk of environmental damage such as oil spills and pollution.

There are various maritime insurance companies and P&I clubs to cover such risks if any damage occurs to the parties during the carriage. The P&I insurance is a form of mutual maritime insurance provided by a P&I Clubs.

In early days, to cover the loss during the carriage of goods, the ship owners and charterer would seek underwriters to insure their ships and cargo owners would insure their cargoes. But as the time passed by, gradually the ship owners felt the need of third party indemnity as they might themselves be at fault and that need led to the birth of P&I clubs.

As the P&I clubs started becoming prominent in the late 19th century, the risk of liability for cargo carried by the inured hip was added to the insurance cover provided by the P&I clubs. The P&I clubs started catering to the loop holes that were present in the marine insurance, which proved to be highly beneficial to the marine industry at large. It was after the famous Torrey Canyon grounding in 1967, covering the liabilities, costs and expenses of oil spills became an increasingly important aspect of P&I insurance.

P&I CLUBS BEATS MARINE INSURANCE

Marine insurance offers insurance on limited risks unlike the P&I club, the marine insurance insures hull and machinery for ship owners and cargos to the cargo owner. The extended edge of P&I club is that they cover third party risks like a carrier’s liability to a cargo owner for damage to cargo, a ship owner’s liability after a collision, environment pollution and P&I war risk insurance, or legal liability due to acts of war affecting the ship.

Marine insurance are usually profit organization as they charge premiums to the customers to fully cover the ships and the cargos but in case of P&I Clubs, it runs as non-profit as they arefinanced by “calls”. The club members contribute to the club’s common risk pool according to the Pooling agreement entered between the members. In case the risk pool cannot cover the claim then the members are asked to pay further call and if the risk pool has excess cover then the members are asked for lower call.

The ship owners with acceptable reputation are eligible to join the P&I Club and the member who incurs reckless or avoidable loss to the club is asked to leave.

The shipper or the cargo owner is covered by a marine insurer and the carrier or ship owner are covered by the P&I club. If the cargo is lost or damaged, the cargo-owner needs to first make a claim against the ship owner. Moreover, the shipowner can avoid the liability if there exists prima facie no error on the part of the carrier or if the Hague-Visby rules grant exemption from liability. In such scenario where the carrier or ship owner is not under any obligation, the cargo owner can approach the marine insurance company to realize its claim. Statistically, 90 % of the world maritime tonnage is covered by the mutual P&I Clubs.

A FEW MAJOR P&I CLUBS

Some of the prominent P&I clubs worldwide are:

  • Steamship Mutual Management
  • Japan Shipowners P&I Association
  • Standard Steamship Owners Protection & Indemnity Association
  • Michael Else & Co.
  • London Steam-ship Owners Mutual Insurance
EXCEPTION TO P&I COVERAGE
  • Other Insurance: A P&I insurance claim may be rejected if club managers think the risk should have been covered by other types of insurance that the ship owner should have obtained, such as war risks insurance or hull insurance, which pays collisions liabilities and, in some cases, liabilities for damages to fixed and floating objects (“FFO”).
  • Mutuality: A claim may be rejected in part or full if the ship-owners didn’t take sufficient steps to limit its liability in order to protect the Club. The Club requires ship owners to ensure that the text within bills of lading and passenger tickets minimizes the ship-owner’s liability faults. The Club expects the Ship-Owners to comply with all flag state requirements concerning marine safety and environmental protection.
  • Moral hazard: Liabilities due to the fraudulent non-delivery of cargo, especially deliveries of cargo that not require an original bill of lading, are usually not covered by P&I insurance. This view is reflected in the decision of the English Courts in Sze Hai Tong Bank v. Ramber Cycle Co.
  • Willful misconduct: Losses intended by the insured, or which it “turned a blind eye” knowing they were likely to happen.
  • Public policy: Criminal liabilities are not covered as a matter of course. A criminal liability is imposed only for intentional misconduct. Presently, statutes in many countries impose “Criminal” liability for negligent conduct that damages the environment, under circumstances that do not rise to the level of “Willful misconduct” under the law of marine insurance.
BENEFITS BEING ASSOCIATED WITH P&I CLUBS
  • Risks covered by a P&I Club:
    • Personal injury/illness/death
    • Collision
    • Wreck removal
    • Damage to fixed and floating objects
    • Pollution
    • others
  • Role of the Club
    • Manage claims
    • Act as central point of contact
    • Appoint experts, lawyers and correspondents
    • 24 hour emergency response
    • Pay claims and fees incurred
    • Advise on safety and loss prevention
    • Arrest or threat of arrest of an entered ship
    • Club letters of undertaking
    • Arrangement of bank guarantees

About Author

Pradeep Jain

Pradeep K Jain is the Managing Partner at Singhania & Co., Mumbai Office, and an expert in Maritime and Corporate Law.

Nalini Mishra

Nalini Mishra - Senior Associate