×

or

“Skill to Chance” Game Over! The High Stakes of India’s Real-Money Gaming Revolution

“Skill to Chance” Game Over! The High Stakes of India’s Real-Money Gaming Revolution

In In the span of less than two decades, India’s real-money online gaming industry grew from a niche, largely misunderstood sector to a multibillion-dollar powerhouse—and then faced an unprecedented regulatory reckoning. This sector, once touted as the frontier of digital entertainment and fintech innovation, is now navigating the most disruptive chapter in its history following the passage of the Promotion and Regulation of Online Gaming Act, 2025, which imposed a sweeping nationwide ban on all forms of real-money games, whether of skill or chance.

The journey to this point has been anything but straightforward. It reflects a complex interplay between entrepreneurship, technology, state and central regulation, constitutional principles, and social concerns. What began as small-scale rummy portals and fantasy sports apps has, over the years, drawn billions in venture capital, generated massive user bases, and sparked heated debates about the very definition of gambling versus skill-based entertainment in India.

FROM COURTS TO CODE: EARLY LEGAL FOUNDATIONS

The foundation for India’s gaming jurisprudence was laid decades before smartphones or mobile apps became part of everyday life.

In 1957, the Supreme Court, in a landmark ruling, drew a distinction between games of pure chance and those involving substantial skill. This doctrine, which treated skill-based games as legitimate business activities protected under Article 19(1)(g) of the Constitution, became the legal bedrock for operators of rummy, poker, and later, fantasy sports.

This principle was reinforced in subsequent judgments, including the 1967 ruling recognizing rummy as a game of skill and the 1996 verdict classifying horse racing betting as skill-based. These decisions would later become pivotal in battles fought by online platforms seeking to differentiate themselves from gambling outfits.

THE BOOM: A DIGITAL GOLD RUSH

The mid-2010s witnessed a surge in smartphone adoption, cheap mobile data, and a vibrant start-up culture. These factors converged to fuel the explosive growth of India’s online gaming ecosystem.

States like Sikkim (2008) and Nagaland (2015) experimented with progressive laws to license and regulate online skill-based games, paving the way for companies to operate within a semiformalized framework.

Fantasy sports platforms such as Dream11, along with rummy and poker apps like MPL, Games24x7, WinZO, and PokerBaazi, rapidly scaled up. By 2024, India had nearly 490 million online gamers, with real-money gaming contributing nearly 86% of total industry revenues. The sector attracted over `25,000 crore in venture funding and became a significant source of tax revenue, particularly after the imposition of a uniform 28% GST on entry amounts starting October 2023.

For a brief period, India was poised to become one of the world’s largest regulated gaming markets. The gaming economy was not just about leisure—it created over 200,000 direct and indirect jobs, ranging from game design and tech development to marketing, customer service, and fintech integrations like UPI-based microtransactions.

CONFLICT: STATES VS JUDICIARY

Even as platforms scaled up, concerns around addiction, financial distress, and rising cases of fraud and suicide linked to online gaming began to dominate headlines. Several state governments responded by enacting sweeping bans. Telangana (2017) and Andhra Pradesh (2020) were among the first to outlaw online games played for stakes, regardless of skill.

However, these state-level prohibitions often clashed with constitutional protections for business and free trade. Courts stepped in repeatedly to strike down overbroad laws, as seen in the Madras High Court’s 2021 judgment invalidating Tamil Nadu’s blanket ban and the Karnataka High Court’s 2022 ruling against similar restrictions.

This created a patchwork of conflicting legal regimes: in some states, games like rummy and fantasy sports were perfectly legal, while in others, they were deemed criminal activities.

By 2023, the legal landscape had become a tug-of-war between state legislatures and high courts, with companies caught in the middle. Compliance became a nightmare, and even as central rules under the IT Act introduced self-regulatory frameworks, uncertainty persisted.

CENTRAL INTERVENTION: TAXES AND OVERSIGHT

Recognizing the sector’s economic significance, the central government stepped in with two key moves in 2023:

  1. IT Rules Amendments (April 2023): For the first time, online real-money games were formally defined and brought under a self-regulatory regime. Platforms were required to verify user identities, implement grievance redressal systems, and seek certification from government-recognized SROs.
  2. Tax Overhaul: The Finance Act, 2023 introduced a flat 30% TDS on net winnings, removing earlier exemptions. In July 2023, the GST Council went further, mandating 28% GST on the entire face value of bets, treating skill games at par with casinos and betting.

This triggered legal challenges, with companies arguing that skill-based contests should not be taxed like gambling.

While these measures brought clarity on some fronts, they also squeezed margins and raised costs for both operators and players.

THE BAN: GAME OVER

In August 2025, Parliament took the most dramatic step yet. The Promotion and Regulation of Online Gaming Act, 2025 was passed, creating a centralized regulatory body to oversee e-sports and casual games while completely banning all real-money games, regardless of whether they were skill-based or chance driven. Effective August 22, 2025, popular apps like Dream11, MPL, My11Circle, and WinZO suspended their real-money contests. This move overnight disrupted an industry worth billion:

  • 1,700 companies were directly impacted.
  • 200,000+ jobs were at risk.
  • GST revenues projected between `10,000–`20,000 crore annually faced sharp declines.
  • UPI transactions in gaming categories dropped by 26% month-on-month in August 2025.

For users, the ban meant sudden loss of access to platforms they had invested time and money into. For the government, it was a response to mounting social concerns. Critics, however, called it a blunt instrument that ignored judicial precedents and stifled innovation.

FALLOUT AND THE ROAD AHEAD

The immediate aftermath saw chaos:

  • Mass layoffs, with MPL announcing a 60% staff cut and Games24x7 trimming 70% of its workforce.
  • High-profile sponsorship deals in cricket and other sports were abruptly canceled.
  • Legal challenges mounted, with companies petitioning various High Courts. By September 8, 2025, the Supreme Court consolidated all cases and is now set to decide on the Act’s constitutionality in 2026.

Meanwhile, e-sports and non-monetary gaming categories have been carved out as growth areas under the new law, with the government aiming to promote them as part of India’s digital economy vision.

CONCLUSION: A DEFINING CROSSROADS

The story of India’s real-money online gaming industry is a cautionary tale about innovation, regulation, and societal values. From early court victories that celebrated the role of skill, to meteoric growth fuelled by technology and investment, and finally to a nationwide ban that redefines the sector’s future, this journey reflects the challenges of governing a digital-first economy.

As the Supreme Court deliberates, the fate of thousands of jobs, billions in revenue, and India’s reputation as a hub for tech-driven entertainment hangs in the balance. Whether the future holds a revival through nuanced regulation or a permanent shift toward non-monetary gaming, one thing is clear: the stakes have never been higher.

As we trace this fascinating journey, it becomes clear that the evolution of India’s real-money gaming industry has been marked by pivotal moments of growth, disruption, and legal reckoning. To truly understand the sector’s rise and its eventual collapse, it is essential to revisit the key milestones—from early court decisions that shaped the definition of skill versus chance, to the patchwork of state laws, and finally to the sweeping central ban of 2025.

The following timeline offers a chronological narrative, capturing every critical legal, regulatory, and judicial turning point that has defined the fate of online real money gaming in India.

LEGAL TIMELINE OF REAL-MONEY ONLINE GAMING IN INDIA

A comprehensive chronology of every major legal, judicial, and regulatory development shaping the online real-money gaming industry – from early court doctrines to the nationwide ban and ongoing Supreme Court battle.

EARLY LANDMARK COURT RULINGS (1957–1996)
  • 9 April 1957 – Skill vs Chance Doctrine

RMD Chamarbaugwalla case: Supreme Court holds that games where skill predominates are not gambling. Gambling is not protected as a business under Article 19(1)(g), giving states power to regulate or prohibit it.

  • 22 November 1967 – Rummy Protected

State of Andhra Pradesh vs K. Satyanarayana: Rummy is “mainly and preponderantly a game of skill,” not gambling. This distinction becomes the foundation for later defenses of online skill games.

  • 12 January 1996 – Horse Racing Classified as Skill

Dr. K.R. Lakshmanan vs State of Tamil Nadu: Horse racing requires skill and informed prediction, so wagering on races is not gambling.

EARLY STATE REGULATIONS (2008–2016)
  • 2008 – Sikkim Licensing Law

Sikkim enacts India’s first online gaming licensing framework, initially allowing statewide play, later restricted to intranet parlours within state boundaries.

  • 2015 – Nagaland Skill Game Regulation

Nagaland introduces a licensing regime exclusively for online skill games like poker, rummy, chess, and fantasy sports, with pan-India applicability where local laws permit.

PLATFORMS RISE & STATE-LEVEL BANS (2017–2020)
  • April 2017 – Fantasy Sports Gain Legal Recognition
  • P&H High Court (Varun Gumber case): Dream11 fantasy contests deemed games of skill and legitimate business. SC later upholds this by dismissing appeals.

  • June–July 2017 – Telangana Blanket Ban
  • Telangana removes the skill exemption, banning all stake-based online games, including rummy and fantasy sports.

    • Rummy platforms challenge the law; HC grants partial relief, allowing operations outside Telangana but no stay within the state.
  • 2 December 2020 – Andhra Pradesh Ban
  • Andhra Pradesh passes similar blanket ban citing addiction concerns. Offenses are made cognizable and non-bailable. – 2023: HC sets up a committee to determine if rummy is a game of skill or chance (pending).

STATE VS JUDICIARY SHOWDOWNS (2021–2023)
  • Feb 2021 – Tamil Nadu Blanket Ban (First Law)

Prohibits all stake-based games, even chess tournaments with prizes.

  • 3 Aug 2021 – Madras HC Quashes Ban

Declares total ban unconstitutional and excessive. Affirms rummy and poker as skill games.

  • 28 Sept 2021 – Kerala HC Quashes Rummy Ban

Rules rummy remains a game of skill even online; state cannot arbitrarily classify it as gambling.

  • Oct 2021 – Karnataka Blanket Ban Introduced

Outlaws all online stake-based games, but exempts horse racing.

  • 14 Feb 2022 – Karnataka HC Strikes It Down

Finds the law disproportionate and discriminatory. Quote: “Game of skill played with or without stakes is not gambling.”

  • Oct 2022 – Tamil Nadu’s Second Law

Bans online games of chance, controversially listing rummy and poker as chance games. Creates Tamil Nadu Online Gaming Authority.

  • 9 Nov 2023 – Madras HC Partial Upholding
    • Upholds regulatory framework and state power to curb gambling.
    • Removes rummy and poker from “games of chance”, keeping them legal skill games.
CENTRAL GOVERNMENT ACTIONS (2023)
  • March 2023 – Finance Act Overhaul
    • Section 115BBJ: 30% tax on net winnings from all online games.
    • Section 194BA: Platforms must deduct 30% TDS at withdrawal/year-end; no `10,000 threshold.
  • 6 April 2023 – IT Rules Amended
    • Defines “online real-money game”.
    • Creates Self-Regulatory Bodies (SRBs) to certify permissible games.
    • Mandates KYC, risk disclosures, and grievance redressal for gaming intermediaries.
  • 11 July 2023 – GST at 28%
    • GST Council announces 28% tax on full stake value, treating skill games like betting/gambling.
    • Effective Oct 1, 2023.
    • Industry files writ petitions challenging classification; Supreme Court consolidates and reserves judgment on 12 Aug 2025.
TAMIL NADU JUDGMENT RECAP (NOV 2023)
  • Court balances regulation with constitutional rights:
    • State can regulate online games and impose restrictions.
    • Rummy and poker explicitly protected as skill games, cannot be classified as gambling.
PARLIAMENT’S LANDMARK MOVE: NATIONAL BAN (AUG 2025)
  • 20–22 Aug 2025 – Promotion and Regulation of Online Gaming Act, 2025
    • Nationwide ban on all online real-money games, regardless of skill or chance.
    • Criminalizes participation, facilitation, and advertising.
    • Sets up National Online Gaming Commission for oversight.
    • E-sports and non-monetary social games remain legal.
IMMEDIATE FALLOUT (AUG–SEPT 2025)
  • Platforms like Dream11 and MPL shut money-game operations overnight.
  • Mass layoffs across gaming companies.
  • Sponsorships collapse, including major cricket leagues.
  • Sharp drop in UPI transactions linked to gaming.
COURT CHALLENGES & SUPREME COURT INTERVENTION
  • Late Aug 2025:
    • Multiple High Court petitions (e.g., A23 Rummy, Bagheera) argue the law violates Articles 14, 19(1)(g), and 21, treating skill games like gambling.
  • 30 Aug 2025: Karnataka HC refuses interim stay, ban remains in force.
  • 8 Sept 2025: Supreme Court consolidates all petitions and bars further High Court filings.
  • Two major questions now pending before SC:

    1. Constitutionality of the national ban.
    2. Validity of 28% GST on skill gaming.
THE NUMBERS BEHIND THE BAN – INDUSTRY IMPACT

The nationwide ban on real-money online gaming has caused a massive economic shock, hitting companies, investors, jobs, and government revenues. Here are the key India focused statistics that highlight the scale of disruption:

  • Companies Impacted: Over 1,700 startups operating in real-money gaming are directly affected by the ban.
  • Jobs at Risk: Nearly 200,000 employees face job losses across gaming platforms, marketing, and support services.
  • MPL Layoffs: Mobile Premier League (MPL) has already announced layoffs of 60% of its India workforce (around 300 of 500 employees).
  • Industry Size Before Ban: The sector was valued at approximately $3.7 billion (`31,000 crore) by FY2024–25.
  • Share of RMG in Gaming Revenue: Real money gaming accounted for 85.7% of total gaming revenues, showing why the ban is so disruptive.
  • GST Revenue at Risk: The government could lose `20,000 crore annually in GST collections due to the shutdown of RMG operations.
  • Investments in Danger: An estimated `25,000 crore of domestic and foreign investments are now at risk.
  • Players’ Annual Losses: Indian players were losing a combined `20,000 crore annually, with 450 million users participating in real-money games.
  • Tax Impact Post-GST: GST collections from online gaming had grown by 412%, reaching `6,909 crore in a six-month period before the ban.
  • Revenue Declines Post-28% GST: In a survey of 12 companies, 7 reported stagnant or declining revenues, with 2 reporting drops of up to 50%.
  • Examples of Scale: WinZO, one of India’s largest platforms, posted revenues of `1,055 crore in FY2023–24, showing the size of individual players in the sector.
  • Companies Facing Closure: Over 400 small and mid-sized companies may face closure or significant downsizing due to the ban.
GAME ON?
  • Legal today: e-sports and non-stake games.
  • Industry pivots to ad-funded, subscription-based models.
  • 2026 Supreme Court verdicts will decide:
    • Whether real-money skill games can return.
    • Whether GST will continue at punitive rates.
  • Courts consistently protected skill games, but lawmakers kept tightening regulations.
  • Central taxation in 2023 reshaped economics of the industry.
  • 2025 ban marks a historic reversal, overriding decades of judicial precedent.
  • Supreme Court now holds the final word on the sector’s future.
GLOBAL REGULATORY JOURNEYS OF REAL-MONEY ONLINE GAMING

Real-money online gaming has seen a remarkable evolution across jurisdictions, with countries taking different approaches depending on legal traditions, cultural sensitivities, and economic priorities. While some regions have embraced comprehensive licensing regimes, others have chosen prohibition or partial permissions. Many have transitioned over time from unregulated grey markets to highly structured frameworks.

FULLY LICENSED AND REGULATED MARKETS

These countries treat online gaming as a regulated activity, with licensing, taxation, and strict oversight.

  • United Kingdom
  • The Gambling Act 2005 established a unified framework for remote gambling. The UK Gambling Commission (UKGC) oversees licensing, advertising standards, responsible gaming measures, and anti money laundering (AML) compliance. Recent updates include enhanced affordability checks and real-time data reporting.

  • Netherlands
  • The Remote Gambling Act (KOA), effective in 2021, introduced strict licensing rules and Cruks, a central self-exclusion registry. Operators are held to high duty-of-care standards, and enforcement against unlicensed operators has been a key focus.

  • Germany
  • The Interstate Treaty on Gambling (GlüStV 2021) unified previously fragmented laws, legalising online slots, poker, and sports betting with uniform federalstate oversight. Regulations include deposit caps, stake limits, and advertising restrictions.

  • Spain
  • Spain has gradually tightened its laws with advertising bans and a “safer gambling” framework aimed at protecting young adults. Licensed operators face continuous monitoring and reporting obligations.

  • Italy
  • A 2024 reform reorganised licensing structures, responsible gaming mandates, and AML compliance, bringing Italy in line with contemporary European standards.

    Partial Permission with Strict Carve-Outs

    Certain jurisdictions permit specific products, while others remain prohibited or state-controlled.

  • Australia
  • The Interactive Gambling Act bans online casino and poker but allows state-regulated online sports betting. The Australian Communications and Media Authority (ACMA) plays a key role in blocking unlicensed operators and advertisements.

  • Singapore
  • The Gambling Control Act 2022 introduced a consolidated licensing system with narrow authorisations. Unlicensed gambling, including remote operations, faces strict criminal penalties.

  • New Zealand
  • Remote gambling is prohibited unless offered by state entities such as Lotto NZ. This approach prioritises public health by limiting access to online platforms.

PROHIBITION AND STRICT CONTROLS

Some countries maintain comprehensive bans on real-money online gaming.

  • China
  • All private online gambling is prohibited, with only state lotteries operating legally. Enforcement includes censorship, payment blocks, and criminal penalties.

  • United Arab Emirates
  • Historically operated under a complete ban, but in 2023, a federal gambling authority was created to explore tightly controlled licensing, marking a cautious step toward regulation.

TRANSITIONING FROM GREY MARKETS TO STRUCTURED SYSTEMS

Many countries have moved from loosely regulated environments to formalised  frameworks.

  • Brazil
  • Fixed-odds betting was legalised in 2018, followed by a comprehensive federal regime under Law 14,790/2023. Current efforts focus on licensing, taxation, AML requirements, and blocking unlicensed operators.

  • Philippines
  • Domestic e-gaming licences continue to expand, while offshore-facing POGOs are being phased out to address corruption and security concerns.

  • Kenya
  • Evolving reforms now mandate AML compliance, disclosure of beneficial ownership, and stricter licensing procedures for operators.

UNITED STATES: STATE-BY-STATE EVOLUTION

The 2018 repeal of PASPA enabled states to regulate independently:

  • Sports betting is legal online in more than 30 states, each with distinct rules and tax structures.
  • Online casino gaming (iGaming) is legal in states like New Jersey and Michigan.
  • This creates a varied national landscape with different compliance standards and enforcement mechanisms.
COMMON REGULATORY MECHANISMS

Across jurisdictions, certain tools are consistently employed:

  • Licensing and KYC: Centralised systems requiring real-name verification and self exclusion registers.
  • Advertising and Payment Controls: Marketing restrictions and payment blocking to combat illegal operators.
  • AML Oversight: Stringent checks on operators and shareholders.
  • Market Consolidation: Phasing out illegal platforms as legal, licensed ecosystems grow.
GLOBAL LANDSCAPE SNAPSHOT
  • Europe hosts some of the most mature frameworks, with strong consumer protection measures and national variations under EU principles.
  • Asia-Pacific ranges from prohibitionist (China, UAE) to tightly managed models (Singapore, Australia) and transition economies (Philippines).
  • Americas are rapidly evolving, with Brazil’s new national system and the United States’ diverse state-level models.
  • Middle East shows signs of future openings through highly centralised regulation.

About Lex Witness

Lex Witness Bureau

The LW Bureau is a seasoned mix of legal correspondents, authors and analysts who bring together a very well researched set of articles for your mighty readership. These articles are not necessarily the views of the Bureau itself but prove to be thought provoking and lead to discussions amongst all of us. Have an interesting read through.