
or
Law is a normative value to help society live in collectivity and harmony. For law to be a supreme regulator of all, it must become integral in theory and practice. An integral dimension of law helps State, society and legal systems to balance and harmonize competing claims arising out of complexity and heterogeneity of life and changing needs. Professor Dr. K. Parameswaran outlines his integral theory of law in this series of articles by showing how law must integrate knowledge from other disciplines; bring them under what law wants from them.
There are several approaches currently in practice that study this interdisciplinary relationship between law and management. They can be broadly classified into; law and management, legal management and business laws. All these three areas largely hold the entire gamut of inter-relationships between business and society. These interdisciplinary relationships also cover social responsibility, corporate governance, administration, ethics, brand value, goodwill, marketing, competitiveness and several other aspects of economics, sociology, behavioral science, commerce, public good, human rights etc. All these studies – law and management, legal management and business laws have their own concerns and their insufficiencies are addressed in the integral dimension of law between law and management.
When law and its legal systems under State and its Constitution have a ubiquitous role in society, all organizations and entities have to study law and its overarching roles and functions in their respective domains. All disciplines of knowledge and their operations in the end, come to law for final refuge of legal rescue. Legal impact on all kinds of social and economic environment needs law and legal systems for orderly functioning of mutual relations.
Management as a discipline with all kinds of functions and their respective skills relate to any organization through finance, strategy, human resource, personnel, labor, operations etc. Management plays a very serious role in efficiency and effectivity of both human and resource relations. Interrelationship between law and management can bring a symbiotic cooperation between socio-economic entities on one side with their intraorganizational affairs or activities within an organization with that of law and legal systems of State and its Constitution on the other side for legalities and regulations.
Then, what should students of law and management study ideally to understand this symbiotic cooperation? There are three stages to this study. First, a preliminary stage where public law concepts and foundational aspects of management are undertaken. Definitions of State, public and governmental authority and its roles, limits and judicial review by a court of law form part of main focus. This cannot be avoided as trade and commerce and its allied issues within India as well as outside India are governed by the important Constitutional provisions like Part XIII – Trade, Commerce and Intercourse within the Territory of India, Taxation, Property, Registration and Entries in the Lists of Seventh Schedule etc., by which corporate houses run and make profits. Other public law concepts like constitutional and administrative law, Montesquieu’s separation of powers, legislations relating to trade and commerce, parliamentary sovereignty, international trade and global governance, impact of globalization on public law, consumption and production of resources etc., also form as sub parts of the first stage. Whereas from management point of view, the art and science of management, human behavior and team management, hierarchy, authority, power, decision making, leadership and ethics play key roles. A second stage is one where private law aspects are brought into and studied with certain boundaries of public law. They are law of obligations through contract, agreed terms and conditions, misrepresentation, breach, termination, frustration and remedies.
Law relating to torts and their liabilities, negligence and foreseeability also play a crucial role in this as sub parts of the second stage. Whereas from management point of view, nuances, values and principles of political, legal, cultural and economic environment in which businesses take place with various inter relational actors, international trade, globalization, technology, innovation, risks and insurance form part of second stage. A third stage is an advanced stage on this interrelationship where foundations of management practices, accounting standards, mergers and acquisitions and frauds are looked into through legal prisms. Provisions of laws relating to crime and evidences come. And from management point of view are alternative development, innovation, resource planning, incentives, returns, project planning and controlling techniques like CPM and PERT.
Third stage is one where conflict between society through State and business through management come. It is in this stage, law and management really converge. Corporate counsels and managers meet here. State systems of law and administration interact with management systems of corporate boards. This is a crucial stage to be studied. At this stage, one sphere of operation automatically impacts the other. In a way, both spheres of operation simultaneously operate enriching and impacting mutually. Thus, these three stages in the study of law and management offer scope to understand relationship between these two interesting subjects–law that regulates social behavior and management that regulates organizational behavior. This study with three stages can also be increased in its content depending upon degree of interrelationships to be studied by students of law and management – Bachelors, Masters or other advanced levels.
However, this interdisciplinary method gives equal weightage to both and gives large benefits to diverse business interest groups, big companies, international collaborations and facilitates ease of compliance. At the employee level, efficiency, competition, motivation, performance and multi-tasking become target goals for appraisal and assessment. This study is best suited for employees in any organization or corporate counsels in any law firms who want to grow in their career ladder to higher positions from midlevels onward in any organization or law firms.
Legal management and business laws though referred as interdisciplinary approaches, it has limited scope and purpose in their interdisciplinary meetings. Legal management is basically for mangers in order to be equipped with legal knowledge and compliance to laws and regulations. Legal management has a basic
Mixture of law, humanities, social sciences, information technology tools and applications. It is also helpful for lawyers and advocates to set-up firms or companies for legal counsels to give legal services. Economics, finance, investment, accounting, marketing, innovation, human resource from commercial sphere and basic laws, contracts, civil and criminal procedure codes, statutory interpretations, taxation, sale of goods, bailments, agency and partnership, banking and negotiable instruments, insurance, shares, taxation, industrial and labor laws, introduction to Constitutional law, IPRs and international trade form part of legal sphere. From management sphere, they are direct andservice management, system-applications, franchise and strategy formulations, advertising, credits, logistics, distributions, production, cooperative management, recording of legal procedures and filing for legal compliances. In case of business laws, it is somewhat straight and clear. It is a study purely of law subjects of legislations and regulations, Acts and Statutes etc. relating to business houses, companies, corporations, governance, mergers, acquisitions, international trade, taxations, insurance, laws relating to obligations, technology and IPRs, competitions, security, infrastructure, energy, property, electronic commerce, registration, trust and fiduciary relations etc. In other words, it is mercantile law or some form of corporate laws in a wider sense. There is neither a management subject to be studied nor management perspective to be analyzed while studying any aspect of business laws. It purely laws applied for commercial transactions.
There are certain real concerns in all these interdisciplinary approaches to law and management. Those concerns are a result of reductionist’s or exclusivist’s approach given to both law as well as management. If law is largely seen as a two-way interaction between State and society based on bigger numerical quantity of democracy without concern of lesser numerical quantity and left out in democracy, such law and its legal systems have serious problems when it comes to State to administer justice, equality, liberty and fraternity. Similarly, if management is largely seen as a two-way interaction between supply and demand, profit maximization and business expansion without concern for sustainability of resources both material and human individuals used, values of ethics and human rights as a whole, such approaches of management will have serious problems when it comes to welfare and wellbeing which are essential for human life and social collectivity. What are those concerns which can be addressed in the integral dimension of law and management? Follow concluding Part II in the next serious of analysis
Dr. K. Parameswaran, Associate Professor of Law, and has been Former Dean at Gujarat, National Law University (GNLU), Gandhinagar, taught at Symbiosis School of Law, Pune, NLSIU, Bangalore, NLU, Jodhpur, University of Madras, Indian Institute of Teacher Education (IITE), Gandhinagar, worked at Publication Department of Sri Aurobindo Ashram, Pondicherry. He authored ‘The Integral Dimensions of Law’ (LexisNexis).
Lex Witness Bureau
Lex Witness Bureau
For over 10 years, since its inception in 2009 as a monthly, Lex Witness has become India’s most credible platform for the legal luminaries to opine, comment and share their views. more...
Connect Us:
The Grand Masters - A Corporate Counsel Legal Best Practices Summit Series
www.grandmasters.in | 8 Years & Counting
The Real Estate & Construction Legal Summit
www.rcls.in | 8 Years & Counting
The Information Technology Legal Summit
www.itlegalsummit.com | 8 Years & Counting
The Banking & Finance Legal Summit
www.bfls.in | 8 Years & Counting
The Media, Advertising and Entertainment Legal Summit
www.maels.in | 8 Years & Counting
The Pharma Legal & Compliance Summit
www.plcs.co.in | 8 Years & Counting
We at Lex Witness strategically assist firms in reaching out to the relevant audience sets through various knowledge sharing initiatives. Here are some more info decks for you to know us better.
Copyright © 2020 Lex Witness - India's 1st Magazine on Legal & Corporate Affairs Rights of Admission Reserved